Lambs kept in custody before crossing the river. (Jimmy Leung)
Everything has finished finally. I took a deep breath by the time I dragged my tired body out of the examination hall. In fact, the Surgical OSCE was not that difficult, only my nervousness had affected my own performance.
Here I have to thank the old, no, (some
crocodiles will ask me how old is old) experienced nurses, irrespective of their ranks, enrolled, registered, or officers, at the out-patient clinics who assisted the examination. Before the start of examination, the lambs were escorted to the designated rooms, standing like a log outside the door, looked agitated, with fine hand tremors and sweating palms. Unlike the cunning crocodile who took a photo of the restless lambs, saying "Don't fall down during the examination, you will only be dragged aside" (whether it is a humiliation or humour, depends on you); the nurses, on the other hand, knowing that the lambs were nervous enough, tried to comfort us by saying "Boys and girls, this is only a minor examination in your life." "Come on, you good boys will be free to summer holiday one hour later!"
We had a label sheet with us during the examination, and we had to give one sticker, with our name and number, to the crocodile inside, or stick it onto an answer sheet once we entered a room. The most shitty thing happened when I found my little label sheet was not in my pocket at the resting station, probably left in the previous room! I waved my hand towards the nurses and a mother-like enrolled nurse attended me. I told her my situation in few words, and without hesitation, she made my label sheet back to me in few seconds. The nurse, probably treating me as one of her children, kept on reminding me to put it back to pocket after taking one sticker. I thank her for not only taking back the labels for me, and also her lesson made me a bit relieved when I was that tense.
The lambs were escorted back into quarantine after examination to avoid any contact with those who haven't sit the exam. No mobile phones communication was possible as they were stripped by the crocodiles. No computers were allowed either as messages may spread through the Internet. Bored enough, we found our own way of making fun, besides discussing the questions and performance, we played around with the little sticker left behind on our hands. Two hours later, the sheeps were freed and started their summer holiday.
----------This is a breaking line----------
Sad enough, some of us were still held within the mouth of crocodiles. Virtually all sheeps attending the pull up viva failed to escape. The more unfortunate ones received the bad news just minutes before handing in their mobile phones at the registration counter, which directly affected their performance at surgical OSCE. You know what, if one failed viva
and OSCE at the same time, there will be no chance to take the supplementary examination, i.e. straight repeat.
To most of us, it is quite the end of term; to some of us, it would be the end of world.
If a pull-up viva does not mean to pull anybody up, what is the point of holding a viva? I know nothing about the marks or the marking scheme, may be some of us really deserve a fail anyway after the viva as the marks are too low, so why don't fail them straightly then? Human beings are still human beings, there are always bias. If a distinction viva candidate is allowed to choose what he is most familiar with, why can't a pull up viva candidate do so? You may say, oh, it's because he had failed. Come on, why don't you give him a chance to show his power, in
certain areas, at least?
You failed him finally, because he cannot answer the pharmacodynamics of warfarin, the pathogenesis of typhoid fever, or name all sorts of breast cancer under the sun, which are, considered
basics of medicine? You may argue, knowing nothing about warfarin will lead to coagulopathy; ignoring typhoid will lead to public outbreak; confusing benign and malignant lumps in the breast may lead to unnecessary mastectomy which is disastrous. Men, we are training
house officers, not
specialogist. Please, let him defend himself. I am sure that he knows when should we talk blood for INR, how to manage a patient diagnosed to have typhoid, and how to approach a breast lump by triple assessment. More than that, he must be confident in telling you what are the ten causes of arrhythmia, what to do if a patient has hypernatraemia or hypocalcaemia, and makes at least five differential diagnosis of acute abdominal pain and relevant investigations.
If you are so fond of those
-logies, please drop two of your fascias in your year three curriculum. One is "Integrated Medical Science", another one is "Junior Medical & Surgical Clerkship". First of all, I see nothing integrated. The examination, I must say, is solely set on the basis of
-logies, to distinguish brilliant lambs in that
-logy, to invite them to vivas and giving them prizes. Secondly, there is nothing in those clinical clerkships can apply. Nothing about signs and symptoms, possible aetiology? A few. Investigations? A little. Differential diagnosis? One. I am sure that if I rely totally on my dear
Yellow Bus, what I get will be a fail, but your notes, is mostly impractical in my future! How can you persuade students that going to wards is better than studying in library? The examination questions, if not far from, then it is not close, to the reality.
I am not surprised to see some really smart guys sweeping medals in those subjects, they deserve the honour. But what made me frustrated is, we don't actually understand what the Tower expected us to learn. The crocodiles must have my question replied in a bureaucratic tone, "Well, we fed our lambs with the best grass, they are herded in the most spacious field," with a hesitation, "Therefore, we expect them to be masters in all subjects, as well as a compassionate, confident, and professional medical doctor."
There is an old Chinese saying, I modified it a bit, "又要「羊」兒好,又要「羊」兒不吃草". Despite the fact that you are taking in the top 1% of lambs in this town, you cannot deny that all of them are just identical. Each of them has its own mind, memory and feeling. They already spent three years' time in the Tower, burning oils, burning all sorts of textbooks and notes, and, their lives. One had already
burnt out last December. Taxpayers have invested a million on each of us, and each of us have invested our springtime to strive as loyal lambs. Although the Tower have to safeguard the quality of her lambs produced, please kindly put your foot into others' shoes and think twice, before ruining our future.
We are little, but not weak.
Some of us being snapped, is because they lost their way in finding a safe crossing point of the river. I have to revise my saying, those being put to the pull up viva, are not those run slowly. It is only they are unfortunate enough to discover the stepping stone. We are naive, and our heart is fragile. Well, heartbreaking can be a way of training, and I understand that it is inevitable in our growth. May some
nice crocodile in the Tower, please, once again, think of their goal of education? How many 赤子之心 you want to break before we graduate? Actually, what does your highness expect us to do? Basic science, or clinical? Not both, please.
p.s. I Hope this won't make me the next sheep to be slaughtered.